On Point With: Christopher Metzger-Timson

Producer, performer, trivia host and “RHONY” star (!) Christopher Metzger-Timson prepares for an epic anniversary this week.


Thotyssey: Hi Christopher, how is autumn treating you so far?

Christopher Metzger-Timson Hey! I feel like it’s flown by! I’ve been traveling a ton, and suddenly it’s almost Thanksgiving. But I love the holidays, so I’m excited!

As a music professional, you must be asked: is it too early now for “All I Want For Christmas?”

It’s never too early for The Queen of Christmas!

Lol, I guess that’s a fair point. Besides hosting trivia, you do a lot! How might you describe all the stuff you do in the music and entertainment world?

I’m the Director of Creative and Production at Broadway Plus, where I produce entertainment for corporate events with Broadway talent. We put on a show to make a conference, gala, business dinner, etc. more entertaining and engaging. The other half of my role is leading the education department, which produces workshops for student groups led by Broadway artists. I’ve been there for four years, and I love it!

How did this all begin: where’s your original hometown, and were music and performance always in your life?

I’m from Long Island, originally–actually, the same high school as Mariah Carey! I studied musical theater at the University of Cincinnati’s College-Conservatory of Music (CCM), and then spent my first decade in NYC as an actor. I toured with shows like Young Frankenstein and Elf: The Musical. Gradually I became more interested in creating my own work, and started to produce and direct in NYC cabaret spaces and nightlife.

In that cabaret world, what stands out to you as a really fantastic experience, collaboration, amazing stage moments, etc.?

I had the privilege of directing (and doing a bit of writing as well) for Carrie St. Louis‘ solo show at 54 Below a while back. That was fun because she had all these hilarious childhood stories she wanted to share, and we got to come up with fun ways to tell those stories through song. A favorite of mine was a parody of “Cockeyed Optimist” from South Pacific that we called “Cockeyed Ingénue,” in reference to fan art that Carrie kept receiving at stage doors that depicted her as cross-eyed.

I also got to collaborate with a mentor of mine, Ben Rimalower, on the early days of Countess Luann’s cabaret residency at 54 Below. That was a wild time. I got to be on a couple episodes of Real Housewives of New York.

Wow, what was that like!?

It was really fun to get a “peak behind the curtain,” and I’ll still get messages from friends I haven’t heard from in years being like “did I just see you on a RHONY rerun on Bravo?” Haha! Unfortunately in my “big episode,” I’m kind of the butt of Sonja Morgan’s joke because I try to get coffee delivered and it takes forever and shows up cold!

Damn! If that happened on an episode today you would’ve had to immediately drop a single called “Cold Coffee.”

[Photo: Michael Hull]

Do you have any overall thoughts about the state of the theater industry? It’s such a weird time with these huge, expensive shows closing early, and lots of shows based on existing properties.

Hm, this is a tough one. Broadway shows have become so expensive to produce that it’s no wonder people feel more confident putting their money into a recognizable property over a truly “original” musical. I think overall, no matter what the source material, if a show is truly well written with great actors then it will resonate with audiences no matter what. We have to remember that long running blockbuster hits like Wicked, Hamilton, Lion King etc. are not the norm. In fact, we used to see way more turnover on Broadway back in the day.

I like to look on the bright side and say how great it is that so many new shows are making it to Broadway–even for a short run. Although I’m sure that’s not a comfort to investors who aren’t recouping! It’s very complicated. I will say some of the most interesting theater I’ve been seeing recently is off-Broadway. I think we’re really seeing a boom of creativity there, as theater makers can take bigger swings at that lower price point.

Intimate cabarets are also having a moment now, or maybe they were never out of the moment! Have you ever produced and starred in your own show?

I did a solo show back in 2018 at The Green Room 42, and it was a blast! So hard, but so rewarding. I would love to do something like that, but I’d need to find the right story to tell. The last one was a sort of “coming of age” piece, so I’d need to figure out a new angle. And get my *ss back in voice lessons, because an hour-plus of straight singing is a lot different than the one song and some banter on the mic that I usually do these days!

Tell us about MT Trivia at VERS, which you host and produce! How did that come about, and what goes down there?

The idea for the show actually started during the pandemic when everyone was going “live” on Instagram. My husband and I started quizzing each other from a Broadway trivia book, and people were playing along in the comments. That turned into a fully produced weekly virtual show on The Broadway Talk LIVE YouTube network (you can still go back and watch old episodes- they’re all on there).

When everything reopened, I knew I wanted to turn it into a live show at a gay bar. The first endeavor was weekly on Mondays at The Q in 2022. That’s where I was able to experiment with structure and figure out how to turn the virtual show into a pub-style trivia with competing teams.

So we play three rounds of trivia:

  1. “A Simple Choice” is multiple choice
  2. “Name that Diva” is where I play audio clips of people singing the same song and you have to tell me who’s singing
  3. “Sing Out, Louise” is the top six teams sending someone up for a karaoke quickfire round. It’s not about how well they singm but if they know the song.

Interspersed with the trivia, we have live performances from our Broadway guest and a “star-to-be.” Prizes can include old Broadway merch items, free drinks / shots, and usually a pair of tickets to the show our guest is starring in. I have to make it difficult, because our returning teams are all very competitive and very smart!

This month [tonight], we are celebrating three years at VERS! The show runs monthly on Mondays from 7-9. The Monday changes every month, so you need to check my Instagram or VERS’ for the date. I’m proud to say we have a very loyal following of devoted theater fans that turn out month after month to compete.

Comic Tim Murray and other stars for the new Traitorz musical will be there this anniversary week as well.

Yes! I can’t wait to see Traitorz. Tim and I have known each other for years, and I think he is just hilarious. We’re going to get a little sneak peek performance as well, and the winning trivia team will take home a pair of free tix.

Anything else coming up?

Our December date is 12/07!

And finally: what is your drink of choice at the bar?

I’m a tequila soda girl as a go-to! But VERS makes a killer espresso martini! I take mine with tequila.

Thanks, Christopher!


[Photo: Marc J. Franklin]

Check Thotyssey’s calendar for Christopher Metzger-Timson’s upcoming appearances, and follow him on Instagram and YouTube.

On Point Archives

4 thoughts on “On Point With: Christopher Metzger-Timson”

  1. So proud of my son Christopher! I am taking credit for enrolling him in his first theater class, “Stars to Be”, at the age of seven. There was no stopping him after that. xo Mom

    Like

  2. Great conversation article with my clever, talented nephew, Christopher, who I’ve so enjoyed seeing perform through the years! Can’t wait to see what he’ll do next! Xo Aunt Patty

    Like

Leave a Reply